
Recipe Provided By: Food & Wine
See more from
Food & Wine on Yahoo! Food
Per Serving
About: Nutrition Info ![]()
Powered by: ESHA Nutrient Database ![]()
Yield: 10 servings
Mina invented this soup in the early days of Aqua, the San Francisco restaurant where he rose to fame in the '90s. He started playing with the combination of black truffles and caramelized onions and went crazy for the mix of earthiness and sweetness. This version of the soup calls for truffle-infused pecorino cheese (sold in any good cheese shop), which is melted to form a marvelously gooey topping for the oniony broth.
The instructions should have called for the use of a higher smoke point oil to be used in conjunction with the butter. The point is to "caramelize" the onions, not brown them.
I would also recommend using a much thinner slice of onion and a lower heat. It's more time consuming but worth it!
Would have also recommended gruyere cheese instead of the pecorino. The recommended cheese was a "low hurdle" way to get the truffle "buzz" in there but, pecorino is a bit more acid and the soup is a bit more lush with the gruyere.
Finally, what about adding a splash of madera or dry sherry to the end product? Makes for a nice finish as long as you stay away from a cream sherry.
12 of 14 found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes - No Report Abuse
My Martha Stweart recipe is still better................why well
it calls for 3 diffrent types of onions and Vermouth to carmelize the onions.mmmmm
10 of 14 found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes - No Report Abuse
First of all, cut this in half unless serving a small army or you want leftovers for a week. I use 1 1/2lbs onions and 5 cups of stock.
Beef is the wrong stock for this soup - any french preparation uses chicken stock, preferrably homemade. The only cookbooks that call for beef stock are American, and this is not an American recipe.
I slice the onions thin, start with 2tbs veg oil and 1 tbs butter, mix in chopped thyme, salt and cook, covered, over med low for 10 - 12 minutes.Then I crank the heat to med high and cook, stirring frequently, about another 30 minutes, until very dark brown (this is where the color comes from, not the stock). Add the stock (make sure it's hot) and scrape the carmelized bits from the bottom into the soup. Bring it to a boil, add a little more salt (depending on the stock, really), 1/4 cup of red or white whine, and pepper to taste. Lower hear, simmer 10-15 mins covered. Then you can gratinee with crouton and gruyere or emmentaler. This will be much better than the preparation here.
3 of 4 found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes - No Report Abuse
Must be good, having pecorino truffle infused, unfortunally being in England (and far from London) it is quite impossible to put my hand on some.
I do french onion soup and also add a dash of cherry vinegar a little plus that makes a big difference. I do not use that amount of oil as you suggest but about 2 table spoon.
As for the cooking time, for the last two reviews, plase note that the onions have to cook in very low heat for a long period of time so it will enhance the flavour and become almost sweet, while cooking the onion very fast will leave you with a bitter taste onion soup. Yes, it is long to make but the results are incredible.
3 of 4 found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes - No Report Abuse
The onion slices are too thick, for sure. All the recipes I have are with white wine and it is delicious. Swiss Gruyere cheese is better to use.
I have not tried this one, but it may be good, all French onion soups are yummy !!!!
5 of 9 found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes - No Report Abuse
100% Hands on Cooking Training Los Angeles CA learn more here.
Hollywood.kitchenacademyCA.comProfessional, Affordable Culinary Training in as few as 30 Weeks.
Seattle.KitchenAcademyWA.com